Megaphone sifted through party platforms, media commentary, and emailed answers to our questions from the parties themselves to see how each party stacks up on homelessness.
Where do B.C.'s parties stand on ending homelessness?
This election it’s been especially hard to get past the doublespeak, half-truths, and scandals. It’s also been hard to see people who are homeless mostly ignored on the campaign trail. Megaphone sifted through party platforms, media commentary, and emailed answers to our questions from the parties themselves to see how each party stacks up on homelessness.
We’ve identified a few key policy areas and evaluated how they plan - or don’t plan - to end homelessness, so you can make an informed choice on May 9.
1. Poverty Reduction Plan
British Columbia is the only province without a poverty reduction plan. One in five children in our province live in poverty. In March 2016, more than 100,000 people in B.C. used food banks. A poverty reduction plan with legislated targets and timelines would lift people out of poverty and save our province money in the long run. Poverty costs us all.
No. The Liberals maintain their “Jobs Plan,” “LIFT: A Plan to Support People and Reduce Poverty” is “the best social program.” This plan does not commit to specific poverty reduction objectives are there are no targets and timelines.
Yes. The NDP commit to implementing legislation to bring in a poverty reduction strategy with targets and timelines.
Yes. The Greens commit to implementing a poverty reduction plan with benchmarks for progress.
2. Homeless deaths investigation
In 2015, the last reported year, homeless deaths in B.C. hit an all-time high. More than one person died on our streets each week in 2015. We expect this crisis will only get worse. Megaphone has called upon the three main parties in B.C. to commit to a Death Review Panel on homeless deaths to find out why so many people are dying on our streets and what action we need to take immediately to save lives. Though this panel is a small commitment, it could signify an important shift in the way our next government approaches homelessness.
No. The word “homeless” is not mentioned in the B.C. Liberals’ platform. Megaphone has not yet received a response to our call for the party to support a review on homeless deaths. Emails from Megaphone to the B.C. Liberals dated April 26, May 2, and May 4, 2017 have not yet received a response.
Yes. The NDP has committed to support an investigation into homeless deaths.
Yes. The Greens have committed to support an investigation into homeless deaths.
3. Affordable Housing
There are currently at least 6,860 people living without a home in B.C. With ‘hidden homelessness’ and the difficulty of counting people without homes, the real number could be more than 10,000. Advocates estimate we need an annual investment of $36 million to address homelessness.
Advocates also call for addition of 10,000 units of affordable housing per year just to keep up with housing need. A challenge with evaluating affordable housing commitments lies in how different parties define “affordable”. For something to be truly affordable, we think someone who is living on welfare or disability should be able to afford it – which would mean housing available at the current shelter rate of $375 per month. It is unclear how many of the affordable housing units promised in the platforms will be available at the welfare rate.
Addressing homelessness is not mentioned in the B.C. Liberals platform.
But according to the Vancouver Sun, the B.C. Liberals promise to “build more multi-family dwellings faster.” The say they will allocate $920 million to the construction of 5,300 new units of affordable rental housing that “will be aimed at B.C.’s poorest citizens.”
The NDP has said they will build 11,400 new “rental, non-profit, co-op and owner-purchase” units per year for the next decade, ranging from supported social housing to market rental. It is not clear at what rate this new housing will be available or what “affordable” means in this context. Their platform says they will reform the Residential Tenancy Act. They have discussed a renters rebate of $400 per year. The NDP has also said they will create a Homelessness Action Plan, a Ministry of Mental Health and Addictions, and institute a Province-wide Homeless Count.
In their platform, the Greens commit to building 4,000 new units of affordable housing per year, investing $100 million per year to renovate existing social housing units, and enhancing the Residential Tenancy Act. They also speak about a coordinated response to mental health and addiction, and have committed to creating a Ministry responsible for mental health and addictions.
4. Raise the Rates
Basic welfare rates have not been increased in a decade. Currently, a single person on welfare in B.C. receives $610 to live on each month. $375 goes to pay for housing, but if a person is experiencing homelessness, they do not receive the $375 shelter amount. They only receive $235 to live on for the month.
As of April 1, 2017, a single person with a disability in B.C. receives $1,033 per month in disability assistance to cover all living expenses. At a basic level, people experiencing poverty in B.C. need to be able to afford shelter, food, transportation, and health care. Current social assistance rates keep people in a poverty trap.
No. The B.C. Liberals will not raise basic income assistance. Social assistance rates will remain frozen at $610 per month as they have for a decade. In the B.C. Liberals’ platform, social assistance is mentioned a handful of times, most prominently in the “Accomplishments” section which states: “4,600 moms and dads get off social assistance through the Single Parent Employment Initiative.”
The Liberals have stated they will maintain support for RAP (monthly rent supplements for eligible low-income working families) and SAFER (monthly rent supplements for low-income seniors) grants.
Yes. The B.C. Liberals have committed to an increase to disability rates of $50 per month.
The NDP says they will immediately increase both basic social assistance and disability rates by $100 a month. They also say they will increase the earning exemptions for all people on social assistance by $200. This means someone who receives social assistance or disability could earn an additional $200 through work before that money is clawed back by the provincial government. “Clawed back” means the provincial government takes any money someone earns beyond the earnings exemption threshold (currently $200) off of that person’s monthly cheque. The NDP increase would bring the earnings exemption for people on social assistance to $400 per month, and the exemption for people on disability to $1000 per month or $12,000 per year.
The NDP has also said they will restore the bus pass program for people with disabilities. The bus pass program, which previously offered an annual bus pass to people on disability for $45, was changed in 2016. The new system removed the $45 annual pass option, and instead asked people on disability to choose between receiving a $77 increase to their monthly cheque, or paying $52 monthly for a bus pass and receiving a $25 increase to their monthly cheque.
The Greens will work with the federal government to provide a Low-Income
Benefit of up to $205 per month for low income families. They have committed to raise income assistance and shelter allowance for persons with disabilities by 50% by the year 2020. They will maintain and enhance existing housing support programs.
B.C. Greens party leader Andrew Weaver has also said the party plans to pilot basic income. But advocates, including Jean Swanson from Raise the Rates, say basic income could come at the expense of other social welfare programs.
The next B.C. government needs to make homelessness a priority. The leaders of our province should care that people die on our streets.
General elections will be held on Tuesday, May 9. Please vote!
Sign in with
My Apology To Dogs*** ~ I like dogs… unconditional love and loyalty, and especially cute when waiting for their dinner. Quite the contrary with humans in B.C. politics waiting to line up at the ‘power-trough’ and be fed with taxpayer dollars. The May 9th election results is quite the precarious quagmire of uncertainty and waiting upon the pleasures of another. Even though the kennel door is still wide open as we wait another 3-4 weeks to see who might be the leader of the pack, the Party with the least votes, the Greens with only 3 seats, could be the tail that wags the legislature.
Even if a recount gives the Liberals the 44 seats needed to form a majority government, [or even 45 seats] Clark would be running around, barking and chasing her own tail wondering how best to keep feeding at the ’Power-Trough" for long. If only 44 seats, and the Liberals vote one of their own members to be Speaker of the House, they’re back to a 43-seat minority government. If they vote in an opposition member as Speaker, they lose control of the legislative assembly. The opposition parties can refuse to have one of their members become Speaker.
Even if the recounts were to give Liberals 45 seats and one became Speaker they’d have just enough, 44, to form a functioning government. This could open up the kennel doors to blackmail from one of their own in a power grab – whenever a disgruntled backbench MLA threatens to jump ship unless they get a juicy bone to chew on. The politicians may seem quiet right now until the recount, but behind closed doors, the teeth gnashing could very well turn rabid – especially concerning the expansion of Kinder Morgan’s Trans Mountain pipeline.
I like dogs and trust them much more than most politicians that are well-known for their siding with the master that gives them the biggest meal ticket. Just my own take on the election, and my apology for comparing ‘Trough-Feeders’ to loving dogs.